Thursday, February 18, 2016

Making the Transfer

This week's readings from the first two chapters of Writing Across Contexts provides an interesting alternative to the traditional way of educating students in regard to written texts. In many ways, it dovetails into former readings from the class, namely David R. Russell's article, "Activity Theory and Its Implications for Writing Instruction," and Richard Fulkerson's "Composition at the turn of the 21st Century" (see previous blog posts). Moving from the traditional, "one-size-fits-all" approach to a more holistic one seems to be the aim of all three texts. In Writing Across Contexts, the emphasis is placed on students being able to transfer and adapt knowledge about writing in one field to be successful in other areas of writing (across contexts). The authors propose developing a completely different curriculum for courses based on a few key principles:

1. Noviceship- The authors argue that students should be seen as "novices" to the field of writing every time they approach a new genre. They suggest that we "write our way into expertise" (39). Said another way, "the student cannot write from a position of expertise, but must write into such expertise" (19). Even an expert in one field must recognize his or her "novice" status when moving into different fields, and this acceptance allows for more flexibility in "transferring" knowledge

2. Transference (and how transfer occurs)- The main focus of chapter 1 was on "transfer." In essence, students must learn to transfer the information they learn from one genre and adapt it to apply to other areas of writing. How to foster this transference is an essential question. Tapping into prior knowledge and assembling, remixing, or retheorizing (p.5) are all ways that former knowledge can be married with new writing tasks, however, discussions continue as to the productivity and method of teaching transfer outright (7).

3. Metacognition-To foster transfer and develop students into more advanced novices, students must become familiar with "the ability to monitor one's approach to problem-solving," or metacognition (41). Self-reflection becomes a key component to the author's argument in favor of the writing across contexts model as it helps a student build bridges from one genre to the next through problem solving.

4. Holistic Mapping- The authors argue that students who know one particular method for writing (namely the 5-paragraph essay structure) only know one path on a vast map of writing roads (41-42). If students are taught the theory behind the writing genres and are equipped with the vocabulary to make the necessary connections between genres. The authors write, "[I]f we want students to practice "better," [...] we need to help them understand the theory explaining the practice, the logic underlying it, so that it makes sense to them" (4). Understanding and dialoguing about the theory requires a working vocabulary of the key terms that will help them make the transference. The argument from one study shows that, "students don't seem to have a language of writing, and without that it's difficult to know if what they tapped was generalized rhetorical knowledge, or whether there was something more specific they were drawing on but didn't have the language to name" (48).

Reflecting on my own past writing experiences and projecting onto my experience with the RUF project, I am relieved to call myself a "novice" in the area of writing to persuade (either donors to support RUF or students to attend). Coupling print media, writing, and a real audience pushes this project beyond the realm of what I have (successfully) attempted before. In this way, I understand the relief both a teacher and student would feel in replacing terms of "expert" and "student" with "advanced novice" and "novice." Teachers are given permission to continue learning in the area they are teaching without having to project a sense of knowing everything while students are given the freedom to grow in place of the constraints of performance. For the RUF project, I understand that I come equipped with a few previously-learned skills. I've also made observations of other projects similar to the one I am working on in order to transfer these observations into my own work. I continue to think about the audience, my own experiences (both in writing and receiving promotional material), and am working to develop the theory (see previous blog post) that will focus my work while helping me draw on prior writing knowledge. This also causes me to be reflective of my teaching experiences and project new questions to the teacher I hope to become. I am able to teach models successfully but would love to see the adoption of a "writing across contexts" curriculum in my professional settings. Some of this seems to be permeating the academic scene on the public school level, but actually developing a transferrable theory of writing that helps students adapt better to a variety of writing genres.

1 comment:

  1. Excellent overview of WAC so far, Stef. Your reflection on you / writing / and the expansion of skill / knowledge /practices is thoughtful, a good way to see our own development as writers and as users of writing / language. I think / hope as "Writing Studies" matures from only a teaching subject to a subject more akin to Bazerman's view of "literate action" we will see the "spread of effect" you seem to be envisioning here.

    ReplyDelete