Tuesday, March 29, 2016

Genre: More options, more problems

In Charles Bazerman's, A Rhetoric of Literate Action, he explains that writing can be complicated because it exists in a rapidly changing world. To understand a piece of writing, you must also understand the context in which it was written and that time has transpired since the piece was created. He uses the example of a letter. When one receives a letter, there is usually an understanding of who the sender is, that time has past since the letter was written, and there are circumstances already known that help understand the content. There is also a dependence upon the mail system to get the letter to you. All of these illustrate the complicated nature of writing. A letter is a genre. There are rules that govern letters, and there are assumptions that undergird this genre. Bozeman writes that, "genres are ways of doing things—and as such embody what is to be done and carry traces of the time and place in which such things are done, as well as the motives and actions carried out in those locales" (24). The, it is imperative to know the conventions of a genre before beginning a piece of writing and to know that those conventions are not the same across genres. Increased exposure to the genre is helpful in adapting to the conventions, but most students who are used to writing in a particular style may struggle to adapt to genre. 

For me, genre has been very difficult with the RUF project because in some sense it feels like there are numerous genres in play at any given time. While I do want to create a rhetorical piece to convince students to become part of RUF or to get donors to provide support, even these two pieces do not use the same genre as the audience and purpose are slightly different. Students will not read a newsletter persuading them to become involved in RUF. Donors usually need more than a flyer with fewer than 20 words in order to be convinced to give. Then, there are flyers, tabling resources, and powerpoint slides that each require different approaches. All of this feels overwhelming in many ways. I'm not natural at persuasion anyway, but attempting to do it in a variety of formats feels very outside of my scope of expertise. 



Speech Acts and Social Facts: I Discover Fire (but don't know how to wield it)


Charles Bazerman, who wrote A Rhetoric of Literate Action, explains that "the more we can write beyond the bounds of constrained bureaucratic prescriptions, the more we gain power to define and represent ourselves in the literate world" (4). Thus, if we can understand the genre, audience, and various strategies of the specific writing situation, we can move out of traditional writing formats with more confidence and success. This is an uncomfortable scenario for students who may have mastered the 5-paragraph essay or who have only been taught a small sampling of composition structures. 

One of the tools writers can use for more influence in their writing is the application of speech acts and social facts. Speech acts are utterances that simultaneously perform an action. Speech acts can be apologies, vows, or declarative sentences that affect a relationship and are recognized as having performed some sort of act such as repairing a relationship, establishing a marriage, or declaring a child belongs to you. "This concept of speech act then provides the mechanism by which our words can influence the world and remedy imperfections in situations. Speech acts change the social world by creating new social facts, which change what we believe, how we interact socially, and how we act in the world. These social facts then may even change our relation to the material world (68). To have the power to harness speech acts and establish social facts would profoundly influence my effect on students to encourage participation in RUF. However, harnessing this power and applying it in some ways feels like the discovery of fire. If I could figure out how to create it and how to cook with it instead of burning down the house, there might be real possibility here, but with the variety of needs of this project and the varying personalities that need to be persuaded, I'm not even sure what "social facts" to encourage with my writing and what speech acts I want to perform with my work. At what point does creating "social facts" become disingenuous or misleading versus discovering social facts and presenting them to others. And really, are there social facts that can be used to support student involvement in RUF? If so, my next task is to discover and apply them to my compositions.


Composition Pedagogies: Varying Approaches to Teaching Composition

If "pedagogy" is the "art, occupation, or practice of teaching" (OED), a composition pedagogy is the art, occupation, or practice of teaching composition, but even with such a definition, Tate et.al in A Guide to Composition Pedagogies, suggest that there are a variety of lenses by which composition can be taught which take variances in people, knowledge, class, and institution into consideration (3). The following are a sample of these various lenses that affect composition teaching practices and can apply to the RUF project or future projects.

Cultural Studies and Composition: The task of defining cultural studies can be a complicated one, and while writing studies and cultural studies have become so closely joined, authors are no longer making rhetorical arguments for their integration, an analysis of a culture's way of life, their everyday practices, and social order (95) are still vital. While I would question why a cultural studies composition course would be part of an English curriculum, this may touch on former articles regarding the development of English departments in general and how they seem to have absorbed most "writing classes" under their umbrella, whether they belong there or not. When new media entered the mix, composition again needed to adapt and change. Inquiry became easier through the use of online databases and search engines. Multimodality in the presentation of writing became much more prevalent. In 2005, when composition took a "public turn" (according to Mathieu), three important outcomes were brought forth: "a series of historical and contemporary studies f the literary practices of marginalized or previously ignored groups; a demand for and emphasis on school-community partnerships and service-learning projects connected to writing projects; and a growing body of literature that engages with activist rhetorics and public sphere theory" (101). In some ways, all of these have led to a questioning of what ideology one uses to approach cultural studies composition. By looking at the biases used to approach certain topics, one can avoid playing into them and instead advance a new frontier of cultural studies.

Feminism and Composition: Laura Micciche, in her article "Feminist Pedagogies" suggests that "feminist pedagogies in Composition Studies emerge from this wider context [the four waves of feminism] and orbit around the idea that pedagogy has the potential, even the responsibility, to interrogate and transform social relations" (129). While it may have begun with feminist goals, this broader definition of transforming social relations is seen in more recent classroom conversations about gender differences, diversity, embracing conflict, and emotions that emphasize valuing personal experience. Application of feminist pedagogy is "more than a set of practices; it is an orientation to learning and knowing charged by social justice commitments" (133).

Tuesday, February 23, 2016

The Tangibles

Here's the work I've been doing to promote RUF with donors. The magnet and rack card will be distributed at our upcoming donor fundraiser in Houston on Thursday, February 25.

RUF Promo Magnet

RUF Donor Rack Card (Front)

RUF Donor Rack Card (Back)

I have also created a newsletter to be distributed to all our current donors as an update on what RUF has been doing this quarter as a way to help donors feel connected to the work that they are contributing towards. The newsletter can be found on the Google course under Stefanie Bennett>Midterm Portfolio.

This newsletter has been the key way that I have worked to integrate what I've learned from class to an actual product that would be distributed to our target audience. I have made the language inclusive as a persuasion technique, hoping that donors will take ownership of the ministry and feel connected to it on a more personal level. To accomplish this, the opening paragraph addresses RUF as "your" ministry, not "ours" (as in my husband's and mine). I also included a "student spotlight" and a "donor spotlight", emphasizing a personal approach. Lastly, I included all of the upcoming events for the rest of the year under the "prayer" section so donors will be encouraged to pray for these events as they approach and then get to see the pictures and read the stories of these events in future newsletters.

Even the magnet is designed to be a more personal approach for donors. We recently received a similar magnet from a ministry we had sponsored, and having their picture on our refrigerator has been a constant reminder of their ministry and our involvement in it.

The rack card is designed to summarize who we are. It is mostly for potential donors who may not know much about RUF and the work we do. That way, even after a conversation or phone call with them, there is something tangible in their hands that they can look at. It also includes all of our connections to social media so they can research us further if desired.

Thursday, February 18, 2016

Making the Transfer

This week's readings from the first two chapters of Writing Across Contexts provides an interesting alternative to the traditional way of educating students in regard to written texts. In many ways, it dovetails into former readings from the class, namely David R. Russell's article, "Activity Theory and Its Implications for Writing Instruction," and Richard Fulkerson's "Composition at the turn of the 21st Century" (see previous blog posts). Moving from the traditional, "one-size-fits-all" approach to a more holistic one seems to be the aim of all three texts. In Writing Across Contexts, the emphasis is placed on students being able to transfer and adapt knowledge about writing in one field to be successful in other areas of writing (across contexts). The authors propose developing a completely different curriculum for courses based on a few key principles:

1. Noviceship- The authors argue that students should be seen as "novices" to the field of writing every time they approach a new genre. They suggest that we "write our way into expertise" (39). Said another way, "the student cannot write from a position of expertise, but must write into such expertise" (19). Even an expert in one field must recognize his or her "novice" status when moving into different fields, and this acceptance allows for more flexibility in "transferring" knowledge

2. Transference (and how transfer occurs)- The main focus of chapter 1 was on "transfer." In essence, students must learn to transfer the information they learn from one genre and adapt it to apply to other areas of writing. How to foster this transference is an essential question. Tapping into prior knowledge and assembling, remixing, or retheorizing (p.5) are all ways that former knowledge can be married with new writing tasks, however, discussions continue as to the productivity and method of teaching transfer outright (7).

3. Metacognition-To foster transfer and develop students into more advanced novices, students must become familiar with "the ability to monitor one's approach to problem-solving," or metacognition (41). Self-reflection becomes a key component to the author's argument in favor of the writing across contexts model as it helps a student build bridges from one genre to the next through problem solving.

4. Holistic Mapping- The authors argue that students who know one particular method for writing (namely the 5-paragraph essay structure) only know one path on a vast map of writing roads (41-42). If students are taught the theory behind the writing genres and are equipped with the vocabulary to make the necessary connections between genres. The authors write, "[I]f we want students to practice "better," [...] we need to help them understand the theory explaining the practice, the logic underlying it, so that it makes sense to them" (4). Understanding and dialoguing about the theory requires a working vocabulary of the key terms that will help them make the transference. The argument from one study shows that, "students don't seem to have a language of writing, and without that it's difficult to know if what they tapped was generalized rhetorical knowledge, or whether there was something more specific they were drawing on but didn't have the language to name" (48).

Reflecting on my own past writing experiences and projecting onto my experience with the RUF project, I am relieved to call myself a "novice" in the area of writing to persuade (either donors to support RUF or students to attend). Coupling print media, writing, and a real audience pushes this project beyond the realm of what I have (successfully) attempted before. In this way, I understand the relief both a teacher and student would feel in replacing terms of "expert" and "student" with "advanced novice" and "novice." Teachers are given permission to continue learning in the area they are teaching without having to project a sense of knowing everything while students are given the freedom to grow in place of the constraints of performance. For the RUF project, I understand that I come equipped with a few previously-learned skills. I've also made observations of other projects similar to the one I am working on in order to transfer these observations into my own work. I continue to think about the audience, my own experiences (both in writing and receiving promotional material), and am working to develop the theory (see previous blog post) that will focus my work while helping me draw on prior writing knowledge. This also causes me to be reflective of my teaching experiences and project new questions to the teacher I hope to become. I am able to teach models successfully but would love to see the adoption of a "writing across contexts" curriculum in my professional settings. Some of this seems to be permeating the academic scene on the public school level, but actually developing a transferrable theory of writing that helps students adapt better to a variety of writing genres.

Tuesday, February 9, 2016

What's My Theory?

This week, my professor challenged me to determine which writing study theory I wanted to use to drive my project. He wrote,

The one thing I may push for as you write / develop this will be for you to demonstrate in one or more ways how writing study theory informs your analyses and your production. Not sure what form that kind of writing would take, but it's something that I think will help you in this project and beyond.

Truly, I wasn't sure what theory I should use to inform my analysis and production. Even more truthfully, I wasn't sure I knew what the theories were to choose from in order to determine which one would be best. 

Thankfully, the readings for today spoke to some of my questions regarding writing study theory. My professor selected three articles from the same professor, Richard Fulkerson, who wrote over a span of three decades (from 1979-2005). In his first article, he identifies four philosophies of composition:

1) Expressive: values openness, honesty, sincerity, and originality
2.) Mimetic: values accuracy of information, sound logic, and truth
3.) Rhetorical: values effectiveness, audience awareness, persuasiveness, and contextual flexibility
4.) Formalist: values specialized features, often at the sentence level or through paragraph structure

My thought was that perhaps these were the "theories" from which I should select, but I wasn't sure philosophy meant the same as theory. However, considering the article was from 1979, I knew from previous readings that the nature of writing studies had changed too much for those to have remained the same. And I was right...

In his next article, Fulkerson addresses my question about the confusion between philosophy and theory. He notes that at the time of his 1979 article, he used "theory" and "philosophy" almost interchangeably, but over the span of eleven years, he had come to change his language. 

Instead, in "Theory and Composition in the Eighties," Fulkerson identifies four elements that are necessary for a full theory of composition. These include an axiological concern, which is the philosophical component and answers the question: what is good writing?; the procedural element which asks the question: "How do writers go about creating 'good text'?; the pedagogical component which asks: "What do we do in classes that help writers do the things that will lead to 'good writing'?; and the epistemological element, which are our assumptions of what counts for knowledge (411 and class discussion (Blalock)). 

Further class discussion into additional articles, particularly by Berlin, moved into the concept of "ideology," which we identified as a cultural construct. We discussed that each person comes to a text or conversation with an ideology that we often cannot recognize in ourselves; we often can only observe other ideologies and comment on them. This caused me to think about what Fulkerson had said about his four philosophies of composition. In his second article, he writes, "based on this four-part model, I preached two main messages: first, what is now a truism, that teachers who claimed to teach without any philosophy were deluding themselves. It is possible to be unconscious about philosophy, or to be inconsistent, but it isn’t possible not to have one […]" (410). In some ways, every writer/teacher of writing approaches a writing activity with a theory, but sometimes we have not thought enough about what theory we utilize and end up using/teaching an amalgamation of the theories. For teachers, this can become a source of confusion for students who are trying to accommodate the teachers' particular version of the jumbled theories. I wonder if ideologies can be similar. Have we just not thought enough about the cultural constructs that make meaning for us? 

I thought this point was especially apropos to the comments my professor made to my blog regarding discovering a writing studies theory around which to organize my paper. However, in after-class discussion, he clarified that, like so much in writing studies, there is no easy answer to this question. I must discover what my ideology is coming into the project. I already have a theory I'm using; my job will be to flesh it out. In this way, I will almost be working backwards into articulating the theory I am already employing. My professor suggested considering the threshold concepts from Naming What We Know to determine which ones I am already employing and use that as the springboard for my theory-discovery. And so, I have my next step...

A few questions:
1. In some places, I used theory and ideology interchangeably. Is this appropriate? Is the theory driving my writing also the ideology behind my work? How are they different?

2. Unfortunately, I have not been able to master Berlin's pedagogical theories in a satisfactory way. Would it be possible to spend some time fleshing them out in class?

Monday, February 8, 2016

Weekend Adventures: Island Days and John Stossel

ISLAND DAYS
On Saturday, my husband and I rolled our cart of RUF advertising materials to the Student Center on campus and prepared to greet potential new students at "Island Days," hosted by the campus. Departments, programs, clubs, and special interest groups all set up tables and distribute everything from flyers to cups to lanyards in an attempt to lure students to their table, where they can then tell the student what they can offer them.

I took this opportunity to tour the ballroom, collecting flyers and various other reading materials for the purpose of analyzing them for initial appeal, design, and best explanations of what the organization or group has to offer. I also looked at the overall table layouts. Which ones appealed to me? Why? I noticed that I did not pick up any flyers that had a white background, but rather, gravitated to the full-color handouts. I also didn't collect any full-page advertisements, although they were available. Instead, I picked up 5"x11" brochures, some of which were only front and back and some of which unfolded into larger brochures. I even polled the others at the RUF table to determine which one had the best "hand-feel." The glossy? Matte? One-sided gloss? Thicker? My next plan is to create a two-sided pamphlet with the essential information that will be given out to students and donors alike. I think streamlining our information, but providing more than the small handout we have now will improve communication with students, even if a full conversation is not possible.

Secondly, I observed which tables had the clearest message. The "Scholarships" table was the most clearly identifiable. It had a simple, yet professional tablecloth and the word "Scholarships" printed across the front. Simple and informative. RUF has a custom tablecloth, but since it only says the meaning of the acronym, students are still left to wonder. In our weekly tabling in the breezeway, when students will only give each table a cursory glance, I feel we need something else to show who we are without needing an explanation at the table.

JOHN STOSSEL
On Sunday, I watched a program on Fox News entitled, "Stossel: Tech Revolution!" In it, John Stossel, contributor to Fox News Business Channel, explores the rapidly-evolving nature of technology and its startling new impact on areas such as politics, self-promotion, and hospitality. In the past, it seems like churches and religious organizers seem to be the last late-adopters of technology, but in watching it, I discovered a new (and perhaps slightly outside the scope of the class) way to connect students to RUF through the use of modern analytics and technology.

What if I was able to take a more data-driven approach to communication with students in years to come? What if I had an electronic survey based on data that would pre-determine whether a student would be interested in RUF or not, and would help me find and connect with students just based on the data I already have about them. Both the Obama campaign of 2012 and the Ted Cruz campaign of 2016 used data analytics to organize volunteers and optimize time. Based on analytics from everything from grocery store purchases, magazine subscriptions, and types of vehicles one drives, analytics are able to determine with a strong degree of accuracy, your political preferences and which issues are most important to you in order to guide the discussion more productively. (Interestingly, the study showed if you own a Volvo, you're probably a Democrat; if you own a truck, you're probably a Republican.) To be able to have some sort of data that would help siphon though the 12,000-14,000 students at TAMUCC would provide us with a better way of targeting those who showed some sort of statistical data that would resonate with RUF.

One study run by the Obama campaign showed that if they placed a picture of Obama with one of his quotes on the website, they raised significantly more money than if they just posted a picture of Obama. If a girl can dream for a while, it seems like some of these tests would be so beneficial to the "campaign" to raise student awareness (and donor support) for RUF. In designing the website, flyers, and newsletters, guiding data would help focus our energies, both in what we design and to whom we direct it.

Doing that kind of research, developing the analytics, and launching it into something that will help us without the budget of a politician seems a little far-fetched. However, thinking through which kinds of students should be specifically targeted would focus our work and might be worth a consideration.

Stossel, John. "Stossel: Tech Revolution." Stosel. Fox News Channel HD. 7 Feb. 2016. Television.